Can we go back to this one now? (ducks)
Pre-Proposal - Visual Identity
- Thread starter fernando
- Start date
- Status
Can we go back to this one now? (ducks)
@TanteStefana Oh... we can do everything we want 
But I think as soon as we are going back to that one, mainstream adoption is going bye bye
But I think as soon as we are going back to that one, mainstream adoption is going bye bye
mage00000
Member
@ JOL Isn't that just a on/off button?
The video that Triptolemoose posted helped me in my acceptance process of the T&C logo.
But.... both have been rejected, so what happens now?
Back to the drawing board? Or just continue using what we have?https://www.dash.org/forum/members/jol.10085/
The video that Triptolemoose posted helped me in my acceptance process of the T&C logo.
But.... both have been rejected, so what happens now?
Back to the drawing board? Or just continue using what we have?https://www.dash.org/forum/members/jol.10085/
Triptolemoose
New member
This was a special case. This vote didn't require a supermajority to win. It was a simple preference vote, which ever logo wins with more Yes vs No votes, as long as the network had 20% participation (~960 MN).
Unless some votes change in the next 10 minutes, Tharp & Clark have won the vote by a 250+ lead and satisfied the 20% MN participation requirement.
Congratulations Tharp & Clark, and thanks to the all the community members who took the time to participate in discussions and vote.
Degratulations for getting paid when the no votes for both proposals were ignored.
Triptolemoose
New member
No votes were not ignored. They helped make up the 20% minimum participation requirement.
Say it whatever way you want, I'm not using the new logo.
Well said, My Fair Lady! Thank you for providing leadership in this crucial matter.
Please don't make this into an emotional/nationalistic Brexit debate. Let's stay calm and let the Masternode votes (in accordance with Core Group guidance) decide.
You should disclose your preference being the result of obsessively shopping the old, outdated Dash logo onto a million pieces of clip art, something nobody told/asked/wanted you to do.
@GrandMasterDash you need to calm the hell down and get a grip. Nobody wants to watch your negativity and hysteria melt down into a full blown tantrum complete with threats to rage quit.
Amanda has provided the thought leadership we needed to rally around our new T&C logo.
All you have to do is follow her lead, or shut up and get out of our way. Pick one and stop your bitching and pouting ASAP.
Dash used to be Darkcoin until Evan decided it would be rebranded, so you can't really use the excuse that you didn't know another rebranding was likely to follow the Xcoin/Darkcoin precedents.
You signed up for Dash's DGBB and are free to leave at anytime if the Masternode votes and Core Group governance hurt your precious little feelings.
Don't stick around here loitering while spreading FUD and making our community toxic; just leave if you don't like the way our DAO and Core Group are running things.
That's it, both of you to your rooms, no dessert for you!
It's too late for that to matter; at this point negativity and nitpicking are just concern trolling because they won't change anything.
T&C already won the vote, so forget about your silly bike lock/slave shackle logo and get with the T&C program (or make a another proposal with a superior logo/branding partner).
demo
Well-known member
The old logo is not voted, so IMHO T&C is legitimated to substitute it.
Instead of complaining, you' ve better demand for this case to become the rule.
A voted decision that has more "yes" than "no", substitutes whatever status quo is not voted.
Will you fund this governance question?
Last edited:
Triptolemoose
New member
To be clear. If the network vote to fund payment to Tharp & Clark in order to use the new branding (I.E. Our chosen branding gets supermajority in the follow-up proposal next month), will you agree to the result of that vote, and switch to using the new T&C logo moving forward - therefore respecting the decision of the Dash DAO (MNOs and Core) regardless of your strongly held personal opinions?
@TanteStefana Oh... we can do everything we want
But I think as soon as we are going back to that one, mainstream adoption is going bye bye
Failure of my sense of humor, I was joking, thus the (ducks) 'cause I figured someone would throw the tomatoes at me
Yes, totally, I have always done this. It's not possible for the outcome to always be in our favor, we all make the same compromises. I have always respected the outcome.
Triptolemoose
New member
Demo says that because the old logo was not voted in, in his opinion, the new T&C logo also doesn't need to be voted in. I'd considering agreeing with this to some degree if it wasn't a budget decision, however, because we will be paying for the rights to use the T&C logo, it really needs to hit the 10% supermajority to receive funding, as that's how the funding works in Dash.
However, if the T&C funding proposal doesn't receive supermajority and community members choose to donate funds to buy the rights (or core choose to draw from their existing budget to cover it, as is their prerogative), then Demo might have a point, and the YES voting community (or core) might not need a supermajority win to roll out the new T&C logo and replace the current logo within their marketing. What are your thoughts on this?
The payment was agreed in Euros direct with core, so not sure how that affects things.
I think it would be a great advertising opportunity to open up the logo to a public competition. Let's say, a $50K prize with the condition that the winner must get super majority. It would highlight the strength of dash's governance, that you can't just walk in and make changes.
I'm not entirely sure about the mechanics but perhaps utilize a non-free sms vote to determine who goes into the final proposal.
Let's not forget that T&C had the privilege of seeing O&Ms entry before all MNOs. They are the ones that made this a two horse race.
- Status