Liquidity Providers original versus Liquidity Providers v2

[qwizzie]

Liquidity Providers Original

https://www.dashwhale.org/p/ds-liquidity

There is a new proposal for liquidity providers, please vote this one down.

This is the new correct version:
https://www.dashwhale.org/p/ds-liquidity-v2

Liquidity Providers v2

https://www.dashwhale.org/p/ds-liquidity-v2
https://dashtalk.org/threads/proposal-ds-liquidity-providers-v2.8668/

In 9 days the next superblock will be upon us and unfortunetely both budget proposals are currently still
approved instead of one budget proposal replacing the other. This means that both budget proposals
could still end up getting paid, which we really need to avoid as that was not the intention.

Anyways i would like to urge everyone to vote in such way that in the end only one budget proposal remains, this means
voting yes on one propsal and voting no on the other proposal.

 

[Jeztah]

Liquidity Providers Original

https://www.dashwhale.org/p/ds-liquidity



Liquidity Providers v2

https://www.dashwhale.org/p/ds-liquidity-v2
https://dashtalk.org/threads/proposal-ds-liquidity-providers-v2.8668/

In 9 days the next superblock will be upon us and unfortunetely both budget proposals are currently still
approved instead of one budget proposal replacing the other. This means that both budget proposals
could still end up getting paid, which we really need to avoid as that was not the intention.

Anyways i would like to urge everyone to vote in such way that in the end only one budget proposal remains, this means
voting yes on one propsal and voting no on the other proposal.

What about reimbursement? Before you lobby to take away something the LPs were promised and consequently never received, please consider pushing for reimbursement.

https://www.dashwhale.org/p/LP-reimbursment

 

[qwizzie]

What about reimbursement? Before you lobby to take away something the LPs were promised and consequently never received, please consider pushing for reimbursement.

https://www.dashwhale.org/p/LP-reimbursment

I'm not lobbying to take something away here, i'm trying to prevent both budget proposals passing on very weak support as one is clearly presented as a
replacement for the other.

Personally i'm more for the original proposal then for the v2 as the original proposal had some decent support (15%) before v2 suddenly popped up.
I decided to give v2 the benefit of the doubt before voting on it but unfortunetely time is running out now and people do need to make a choice which
proposal to suppport and which proposal to down vote.. Hopefully from these two a proposal emerges that can survive the coming three months and maybe longer...

With regards to reimbursement, thats different in this case in my view as the original proposal lost a few battles with other competing budget proposals while struggling to keep above the 10% treshold. End-result was that it missed a few payments before settling back to 15% support. That can happen and is part of the budget system.
There will be a constant battle between budget proposals / projects that could lead to some budget proposals / projects getting only partial funding.

 

[Jeztah]

I just didn't want that proposal to be overlooked by the masses. I'm certainly not agreeing on both either.

 

[tungfa]

I am all for this proposal but think we should stick to the plan
1 proposal , promote for that and done

if it gets down voted , do more promotion in the next round

posting new proposals for old ideas (and then down voting the old once) is just a pain und unnessacery voting (pain)

 

[qwizzie]

I am all for this proposal but think we should stick to the plan
1 proposal , promote for that and done

if it gets down voted , do more promotion in the next round

posting new proposals for old ideas (and then down voting the old once) is just a pain und unnessacery voting (pain)

yeah, i agree with that.