Lingering Budget Proposal - Dash.org

[ericsammons]

Hello,

Since the new Budget System cycle that started on Sunday, the Proposal "Dash.org domain name" still appears on my votetracker (dashvotetracker.com) even though it has expired:

As you can see, the vote tracker picks it up as an existing Proposal, but at the same time, it marks it as "not approved" (red) even though it has enough votes to be approved, and says it is on payment "5/4".

Because of the missed payment in December, this Proposal was only paid three times (see here), yet if you look at the budget status from dash-cli, you get "RemainingPaymentCount" as zero:

"dash-org" : {
        "Name" : "dash-org",
        "URL" : "www.dashwhale.org/p/dash-org",
        "Hash" : "54e800e5c462a9bbc905ef523058ec76fe6207bcbd547a4cc9d38587eb954728",
        "FeeHash" : "f3233c0c55adbbcabff5c51d841c8c784e15e336882c3acce538bcb921bf9198",
        "BlockStart" : 382168,
        "BlockEnd" : 456940,
        "TotalPaymentCount" : 4,
        "RemainingPaymentCount" : 0,
        "PaymentAddress" : "Xr122HobAmPTQV5qe9jHuwxVVFFCd6P4E3",
        "Ratio" : 0.92183138,
        "Yeas" : 1641,
        "Nays" : 140,
        "Abstains" : 0,
        "TotalPayment" : 8400.00000000,
        "MonthlyPayment" : 2100.00000000,
        "IsEstablished" : true,
        "IsValid" : true,
        "IsValidReason" : "",
        "fValid" : true
    },

I would think the system would ignore the fact that December was skipped, and just mark this Proposal as finished, but it doesn't seem to be doing that - at least not everywhere.

Could someone explain the status of this Proposal, and how we can determine if it is still valid or not?

 

[ericsammons]

Follow-up: If you run the command to see the projected proposals that will be paid next cycle, the dash.org Proposal is NOT included:

$ dash-cli mnbudget projection
{
    "lamassu-integration" : {
        "URL" : "www.dashwhale.org/p/lamassu-integration",
        "Hash" : "19fae1eedd796df4dcdb7a4254d294e0c7cc5f97120eed6db43af7f53ad23861",
        "BlockStart" : 398784,
        "BlockEnd" : 606484,
        "TotalPaymentCount" : 12,
        "RemainingPaymentCount" : 9,
        "PaymentAddress" : "Xs5afpvL2VSvPsPEPutphgA89HCkCXgF8t",
        "Ratio" : 0.93972473,
        "Yeas" : 1973,
        "Nays" : 127,
        "Abstains" : 0,
        "TotalPayment" : 7323.12000000,
        "MonthlyPayment" : 610.26000000,
        "Alloted" : 610.26000000,
        "TotalBudgetAlloted" : 610.26000000,
        "IsValid" : true,
        "IsValidReason" : "",
        "fValid" : true
    },
    "core-team" : {
        "URL" : "goo.gl/V52wZd",
        "Hash" : "eac6392cd0d63e4b2ebd3c60da2d3e13137c892cd4cd1a8f3885077ac86b7487",
        "BlockStart" : 332320,
        "BlockEnd" : 2002228,
        "TotalPaymentCount" : 100,
        "RemainingPaymentCount" : 93,
        "PaymentAddress" : "XtspXMnoGt4RF23CZ7MQQ7NFmkAebMUNME",
        "Ratio" : 0.94201474,
        "Yeas" : 1909,
        "Nays" : 118,
        "Abstains" : 0,
        "TotalPayment" : 117600.00000000,
        "MonthlyPayment" : 1176.00000000,
        "Alloted" : 1176.00000000,
        "TotalBudgetAlloted" : 1786.26000000,
        "IsValid" : true,
        "IsValidReason" : "",
        "fValid" : true
    },
    "soda-reimbursement" : {
        "URL" : "www.dashwhale.org/p/soda-reimbursement",
        "Hash" : "1e477007d555f9f8919ecbe3b4c457b6f269184924771c0117fbb48751bf23d6",
        "BlockStart" : 415400,
        "BlockEnd" : 473556,
        "TotalPaymentCount" : 3,
        "RemainingPaymentCount" : 1,
        "PaymentAddress" : "XdQoPDeEx1iujTJtfGDyivx6b1k6TZ5p6G",
        "Ratio" : 0.89356555,
        "Yeas" : 1835,
        "Nays" : 220,
        "Abstains" : 0,
        "TotalPayment" : 300.00000000,
        "MonthlyPayment" : 100.00000000,
        "Alloted" : 100.00000000,
        "TotalBudgetAlloted" : 1886.26000000,
        "IsValid" : true,
        "IsValidReason" : "",
        "fValid" : true
    },
    "public-awareness" : {
        "URL" : "goo.gl/V52wZd",
        "Hash" : "cbafad18687045bb72fae611078fac09c3ec09c8379e357c36901ce84891f189",
        "BlockStart" : 332320,
        "BlockEnd" : 2002228,
        "TotalPaymentCount" : 100,
        "RemainingPaymentCount" : 93,
        "PaymentAddress" : "XxTqjYd4bpkTA6yP1gmo5maMkPynT6YvbG",
        "Ratio" : 0.88754598,
        "Yeas" : 1684,
        "Nays" : 211,
        "Abstains" : 0,
        "TotalPayment" : 215600.00000000,
        "MonthlyPayment" : 2156.00000000,
        "Alloted" : 2156.00000000,
        "TotalBudgetAlloted" : 4042.26000000,
        "IsValid" : true,
        "IsValidReason" : "",
        "fValid" : true
    },
    "payment-processor" : {
        "URL" : "www.dashwhale.org/p/payment-processor",
        "Hash" : "11bf975fe2fcd8103f598b10fa241c536e4f07c011e9ba03d94afc9a8cf32d6c",
        "BlockStart" : 432016,
        "BlockEnd" : 490172,
        "TotalPaymentCount" : 3,
        "RemainingPaymentCount" : 2,
        "PaymentAddress" : "XcBWystrACF5u2KrsfYHRetrJgxc86UtTB",
        "Ratio" : 0.61327897,
        "Yeas" : 1049,
        "Nays" : 656,
        "Abstains" : 0,
        "TotalPayment" : 1200.00000000,
        "MonthlyPayment" : 400.00000000,
        "Alloted" : 400.00000000,
        "TotalBudgetAlloted" : 4442.26000000,
        "IsValid" : true,
        "IsValidReason" : "",
        "fValid" : true
    }
}

 

[UdjinM6]

System currently doesn't count how many times proposal was actually payed, it only cares about start block and end block for the proposal to be valid.
So this proposal is not valid anymore because its end block exceeds next superblock but for the sake of historical overview (or smth like that, I can't find proper words) it will be delisted in the middle of the next budget cycle (i.e. proposals are listed 1.5 budget cycles more than they need to get payed) iirc.

 

[ericsammons]

System currently doesn't count how many times proposal was actually payed, it only cares about start block and end block for the proposal to be valid.
So this proposal is not valid anymore because its end block exceeds next superblock but for the sake of historical overview (or smth like that, I can't find proper words) it will be delisted in the middle of the next budget cycle (i.e. proposals are listed 1.5 budget cycles more than they need to get payed) iirc.

That makes sense - thanks!

 

[ericsammons]

I've updated dashvotetracker.com so that expired proposals (i.e., ones with "RemainingPaymentCount" equal to 0), no longer show on the page, even if they haven't dropped out of the budget list.