Search results

Terms like “flat system” and “one at the top, beneficial dictator for life with him on top structure” are sensational and ambiguous, but I’d be happy to respond to any specific rules that I’ve violated or specific PO responsibility concerns. The relevant backstory here is that all this started...

I’m not sure if any of the four YES voters have answered you directly, but I am also interested to know specifics regarding this. There are two objective and authoritative documents that define the proposal owner role: https://rules.dashincubator.app/ (specifically...

If I had known these issues were substantive enough to warrant a rogue second Incubator proposal followed by a call for a proposal owner removal I might have brought it up publicly. I was not informed by anyone (neither Andy, nor any of the admins) that this action would be taken, or was even...

My interpretation? Terms I've added in? The rule states: The Proposal Owner can be replaced through a vote where >50% of Admins vote for a new Admin to be the PO ">50% of Admins" seems pretty clear to me. There are currently 11 admins. >50% = 6 admins required. You want to make it ">50%...

Note that according to the current rules… …the number of votes required to change the PO is based on total admin count (currently 11), not the voting admin count.

Obviously my vote is no. I wish I could give an update to my proposal text and comment on this new development (vote to replace me) before I end my day, but summarizing a 9-month long discussion/debate was too much for the time I had today. I'll continue to work on it tomorrow. I would ask...

This is great news. Here are a few links about Patrick and his Dash involvement (since I've seen people on Discord asking to know more about him). I can update this with others if anyone has suggestions, or if I find others. Trust Protector...

Let’s do this next cycle (in about a week)!

I think this recent poll was missing from the original post. Maybe you want to edit to include it @xkcd ? Either way, now it’s here in the comments.

I support this proposal. Thanks for putting such a good pre-proposal together @xkcd! I'm happy to contribute to the proposal fee.

It's a fundamental economic law that both parties who enter into a voluntary exchange of things they own for things they wish to own do so because they consider it in their own best interest. The MNO plan more closely resembles this scenario. If MNOs max out the budget it's because it...

Joel interviewed both sides yesterday: Odysee: https://odysee.com/@DigitalCashNetwork:c/Dash-Podcast-159:2?r=FqowB2QREmrBV4DcLpAWb8cz2K4gYVUV YouTube:

I suspect you are not alone. I think many MNOs will use this reasoning in the future: "Might as well fund more proposals, up to the limit, because otherwise it just get's wasted in heat and electricity from mining, and it really doesn't cost me personally all that much". Not sure where you...

@bhkien, you can comment on the live proposal forum post here: https://www.dash.org/forum/threads/decision-proposal-increase-proposal-system-flexibility-efficiency.50873/page-3 and on Dash Nexus here: https://app.dashnexus.org/proposals/decision-vote-improve-proposal-system-mno-plan/overview...

I like the idea of making vote delegation easier so that incompetent MNOs could have an easy way to delegate their vote to someone more qualified. I don't think **one** single association is the right way to go. I'd rather have certain MNOs (like you) create a document that stated your...

I like the general idea of a document of Dash's mission statement and core values, as discussed in previous posts, but this seems to be taking it to a more bureaucratic level than I'd be comfortable with. Have you read the book "Bureaucracy" by Ludwig von Mises? If not, I highly recommend it...

I think "target markets" should be left to individual network contractors to decided, not the network itself. So for example, DCG can have specific target markets, and Dash Incubator can have a different target market, and Dash itself can decide through normal funding proposals whether, and how...

I read the post, but I didn't read all the comments, so forgive me if this was already discussed there. How would we "agree" on the core values of Dash in a practical sense? Would somebody propose a list to be voted on by MNOs? Would we assume the normal 10% supermajority constitutes...

Great post. The most important insight in my option was the need to have a clear definition of the core values and mission of the project. Many MNOs have varying ideas regarding what Dash is, why it exists, and what is aims to do/build. This naturally leads to different strategies, and a lack...

Well, I think I've done about as much as I can do to help you make an informed decision. I appreciate that you want to optimize the system.